Cottages & waterfront for sale across Ontario cottage country

Cottages For Sale in Carlow/Mayo, Ontario

A rugged Shield township east of Bancroft along Highway 28, where over half the land is Crown land.

Carlow/Mayo marketMedian $1.03M6 for sale~92 days on marketMarket stats

Tap a price to see the home

7 cottages for sale in Carlow/Mayo

27 photos$89,900Land0 bath · < 700 sq ft1703 Boulter RoadCarlow Ward, Carlow/MayoLot 150 x 300 ftCourtesy of: RE/MAX COUNTRY CLASSICS LTD.

43 photos$1,490,000Waterfront cottage5 bed · 3 bath · 5.02 sq ft370 Fraser LakeCarlow Ward, Carlow/MayoGarage · 7 parking · Lot 105.4 x 133.5 ftCourtesy of: RE/MAX ABOUTOWNE REALTY CORP.

43 photos$1,490,000Waterfront cottage5 bed · 3 bath · 5.02 sq ft370 Fraser LakeCarlow Ward, Carlow/Mayo7 parking · Lot 105.4 x 133.5 ftCourtesy of: RE/MAX ABOUTOWNE REALTY CORP.

50 photos$474,900Waterfront cottage3 bed · 2 bath · 700-1100 sq ft529 Mayo Lake RoadMayo Ward, Carlow/Mayo6 parking · Lot 389.1 x 398.5 ftCourtesy of: RE/MAX COUNTRY CLASSICS LTD.

43 photos$1,490,000Waterfront cottage5 bed · 3 bath · 1500-2000 sq ft370 Fraser LakeCarlow Ward, Carlow/Mayo7 parking · Lot 105.4 x 133.5 ftCourtesy of: RE/MAX ABOUTOWNE REALTY CORP.

19 photos$575,000Waterfront cottage2 bed · 1 bath · < 700 sq ft118 Fraser Lake RoadCarlow Ward, Carlow/Mayo2 parkingCourtesy of: EXP REALTY

5 photos$122,000Land0 bath · 5000 + sq ft3995 Boulter RoadCarlow Ward, Carlow/MayoLot 113 x 99 ftCourtesy of: COLDWELL BANKER - R.M.R. REAL ESTATE

Listing data © PropTx MLS®. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Market snapshot

Carlow/Mayo cottage market today

Based on 6 homes for sale right now (asking prices). Updated through the day.

Get recent sold prices

Median asking price$1.03MRange $122K – $1.49M

Homes for sale6Updated through the day

Typical days on market92Room to negotiate

Median price / sq ft$690From listed size ranges

Homes by price

Under $700K3

$700K–$1M0

$1M–$1.5M3

$1.5M–$2M0

$2M–$3M0

$3M+0

By style

Style	For sale	Median price
Waterfront cottage	5	$1.49M
Cottage	5	$1.49M
Land	1	$122K

Thinking of selling here?

See what your home could sell for against these 6 listings.

Get my instant estimate

Cottages and waterfront in Carlow/Mayo

Carlow/Mayo was formed in 2001 from the townships of Carlow and Mayo. The York River and the Little Mississippi River both run through it, and cottages and campsites line the shores of its lakes. Fosters Lake Township Park, off Boulter Road, has a beach, a boat launch and a picnic area. McArthurs Mills on Highway 28 is the main stop for supplies. This is a good area for buyers who want space and quiet.

Communities in Carlow/Mayo

Carlow/Mayo includes Boulter, Fort Stewart, Hermon, McArthurs Mills, New Carlow and Hartsmere. Ask for listings in any of them, or tell us the road or bay you have your eye on.

Carlow/Mayo is part of Bancroft & Hastings County. About 2 to 3 hours from Toronto.

Nearby

More of Bancroft & Hastings County

All of Bancroft & Hastings County

Ready to find your cottage in Carlow/Mayo?

Talk to a cottage specialist today. Honest answers, no pressure.

Contact a specialist Call 647-931-3923

Popular Areas

Useful Links

© 2026 Cottage Connect. All rights reserved. PropTx MLS® assumes no responsibility for the accuracy of any information shown. The information provided herein must only be used by consumers that have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale or lease of real estate and may not be used for any commercial purpose or any other purpose.

The trademarks MLS®, Multiple Listing Service® and the associated logos are owned by The Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA.