Skip to content
647-931-3923 info@cottageconnect.com
Cottages & waterfront for sale across Ontario cottage country
SwipeNEW

Cottages For Sale in Tay, Ontario

Tay Township lines the south shore of Severn Sound between Midland and Port Severn, with waterfront villages at Victoria Harbour, Port McNicoll and Waubaushene.

Tay marketMedian $455K58 for sale+1 new this week~94 days on marketMarket stats
Tap a price to see the home
62 cottages for sale in Tay
Lot 86 - 548 Fifth Avenue, Tay$79,969Land0 bathLot 86 - 548 Fifth AvenuePort McNicoll, TayLot 56 x 112 ftCourtesy of: ICI SOURCE REAL ASSET SERVICES INC.24 Crescent Drive, Tay46 photos$649,900Waterfront cottage1+2 bed · 2 bath · 1100-1500 sq ft24 Crescent DriveRural Tay, TayGarage · 2 parking · Lot 108.3 x 247.9 ftCourtesy of: Century 21 B.J. Roth Realty Ltd15 Swan Lane, Tay8 photos$369,900Land0 bath · < 700 sq ft15 Swan LanePort McNicoll, TayLot 94.6 x 203 ftCourtesy of: HOMELIFE FRONTIER REALTY INC.Lot 2 2332 Rumney Road, Tay8 photos$449,500Land0 bathLot 2 2332 Rumney RoadRural Tay, TayLot 164 x 492 ftCourtesy of: ENGEL & VOLKERS BARRIELot 1 2332 Rumney Road, Tay7 photos$439,500Land0 bathLot 1 2332 Rumney RoadRural Tay, TayLot 164 x 492 ftCourtesy of: ENGEL & VOLKERS BARRIE142 - 140 Mitchells Beach Road, Tay47 photos$1,088,800Waterfront cottage1+1 bed · 2 bath · < 700 sq ft142 - 140 Mitchells Beach RoadVictoria Harbour, Tay2 parking · Lot 43 x 105 ftCourtesy of: Century 21 B.J. Roth Realty Ltd241 Mountain Avenue, Tay14 photos$98,900Land0 bath241 Mountain AvenueWaubaushene, TayCourtesy of: RE/MAX HALLMARK CHAY REALTY10 & 11 Methodist Island, Tay49 photos$499,900Waterfront cottage4 bed · 1 bath · 700-1100 sq ft10 & 11 Methodist IslandPort McNicoll, TayLot 200.6 x 144.4 ftCourtesy of: Keller Williams Home Group Realty15349 ON-12 Highway, Tay$188,888Land0 bath15349 ON-12 HighwayVictoria Harbour, TayLot 91 x 848.5 ftCourtesy of: RE/MAX WEST REALTY INC.134 Forest Harbour Parkway, Tay43 photos$799,900Waterfront cottage3 bed · 1 bath · 1100-1500 sq ft134 Forest Harbour ParkwayRural Tay, TayGarage · 6 parking · Lot 104.4 x 177.3 ftCourtesy of: RE/MAX Georgian Bay Realty LtdLot 13 Park Street, Tay3 photos$149,777Land0 bathLot 13 Park StreetVictoria Harbour, TayLot 75.1 x 200 ftCourtesy of: RE/MAX Georgian Bay Realty Ltd58 Methodist Island, Tay25 photos$899,900Waterfront cottage3 bed · 2 bath · 1100-1500 sq ft58 Methodist IslandPort McNicoll, TayLot 77.1 x 220 ftCourtesy of: CENTURY 21 B.J. ROTH REALTY LTD.

Listing data © PropTx MLS®. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Market snapshot

Tay cottage market today

Based on 58 homes for sale right now (asking prices). Updated through the day.

Get recent sold prices
Median asking price$455KRange $120K – $11.5M
Homes for sale58+1 new this week
Typical days on market94Room to negotiate
Median price / sq ft$615From listed size ranges

Homes by price

Under $700K37
$700K–$1M7
$1M–$1.5M8
$1.5M–$2M3
$2M–$3M1
$3M+2

By style

StyleFor saleMedian price
Land37$215K
Waterfront cottage26$949K
Cottage21$1000K
Chalet1$629K
Log home1$1.49M

Thinking of selling here?

See what your home could sell for against these 58 listings.

Get my instant estimate

Cottages and waterfront in Tay

Tay offers sheltered Georgian Bay waterfront close to Highway 400 and Highway 12. Victoria Harbour, Port McNicoll and Waubaushene began as lumber and shipping ports and now mix older village homes, cottages and newer waterfront houses. The bays of Severn Sound are protected from the open bay, which suits smaller boats and paddling. Sturgeon Bay is another waterfront community. Most properties are easy to reach all year, and Midland is the nearest full-service town.

Communities in Tay

Tay includes Victoria Harbour, Port McNicoll, Waubaushene, Waverley, Sturgeon Bay, Vasey and Old Fort. Ask for listings in any of them, or tell us the road or bay you have your eye on.

Tay is part of Georgian Bay & Simcoe County. About 1 to 2.5 hours from Toronto.

Ready to find your cottage in Tay?

Talk to a cottage specialist today. Honest answers, no pressure.

© Cottage Connect · Will Balo, Sales Representative, RE/MAX Experts
Privacy Policy Terms of Use Photo Credits