58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON L0K 1R0
Port McNicoll, Tay · Near Methodist Island · View map
About this home
A Lake Joseph inspired, finished property on the big waters of Georgian Bay. Enjoy the best boating, fishing, swimming and exploring the 30,000 islands of Georgian Bay. Travel by boat to the local restaurants or supermarkets and enjoy the water lifestyle and beauty of the ever changing landscapes. A rare beachfront property that is shallow and ideal for families. Just 5 minutes from the marina that has a pool, your experience begins on the included 21 foot bowrider. Arrive to the island after enjoying spectacular views and waving to your neighbors as you cruise by. The 3 bedroom, 2 bath cottage has been completely gutted and transformed into a turnkey high end property. New flooring, new kitchen, new appliances, new furniture, new bathrooms and pot lights throughout. With the bonus of a Muskoka room for extra sleeping quarters or peaceful retreat. This cottage can sleep up to 10 people comfortably. The hot tub extends your days outdoors into the evenings with sounds of laughter and joy from the kids. Inside turn on Netflix and watch movies on the 75 big screen. High speed internet when working remotely is top notch. This is more than a cottage, its a lifestyle!
The home
- Type
- Waterfront cottage
- Style
- Bungalow
- Square footage
- 1100-1500 sq ft
- Bedrooms
- 3
- Bathrooms
- 2
- Kitchens
- 1
- Rooms
- 8
- Basement
- None
- Lot size
- 77.1 x 220 ft
- Faces
- East
Ownership & fees
- Ownership
- Freehold
- Monthly condo fee
- None
- Exterior
- Board & Batten
Heating & cooling
- Heating fuel
- Electric
- Heating type
- Baseboard
- Fireplace
- No
Garage & parking
- Total parking
- None
Taxes & other
- Property taxes
- $3,669/yr
- Tax year
- 2025
- Occupancy
- Owner
- Possession
- TBD
- Cross street
- Methodist Island
- Neighbourhood
- Port McNicoll
More
- Price per sq ft
- ~$692 (at 1,300 sq ft)
- MLS® number
- S13588020
No matching details. Ask Will instead
The home and its surroundings
- Carpet Free
- Water Heater Owned
- Mortgage
- Property tax
- Maintenance fee
Cash needed to close
Estimates only, using Canadian semi-annual compounding, Ontario land transfer tax. Mortgage default insurance is added when you put down less than 20%. Your lender and lawyer will confirm exact numbers.
58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON L0K 1R0
Port McNicoll, Tay · Near Methodist Island
Get directionsWhat’s nearbySchools nearby
Open this tab to load nearby schools.
Your commute
Enter where you go every day to see real drive times:
Listing history for 58 Methodist Island
See what this home and others at the same address were listed for, what they sold for, and how long it took.
Sold prices are for members. It’s free, takes a few seconds, and unlocks the sale history on every listing.
Frequently asked questions about 58 Methodist Island
Answers come straight from this home’s MLS® listing.
How much is 58 Methodist Island listed for, and what would it cost each month?
58 Methodist Island is listed for $899,900. With 20% down ($179,980), the mortgage payment would be roughly $3,630 a month at 4.5% over 30 years. Add property tax and the estimate comes to about $3,936 a month, all in. That figure is an illustration, not a quote.
Is 58 Methodist Island freehold or a condo, and is there a monthly fee?
58 Methodist Island is a waterfront cottage in Port McNicoll, Tay. Ownership is freehold: you own the home and the lot. There is no monthly condo fee, so the roof, windows, driveway, snow and lawn are yours to look after.
How many bedrooms and bathrooms does 58 Methodist Island have?
58 Methodist Island has 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. The listing gives the style as bungalow.
Does 58 Methodist Island have a garage and parking?
The listing does not show a garage. The listing does not include a parking space.
Does 58 Methodist Island have a finished basement?
No. The listing shows no basement for this home.
What style of home is 58 Methodist Island?
58 Methodist Island is a waterfront cottage. A waterfront cottage has its own shoreline on a lake, river or bay, so the frontage, the shoreline and the way it faces matter as much as the building.
How big is 58 Methodist Island, and what is the lot size?
The listing puts the home between 1,100 and 1,500 sq ft. The board reports a range rather than an exact figure, and it usually leaves out the basement. The lot is listed as 77.1 x 220 ft.
How is 58 Methodist Island heated and cooled?
Heating is baseboard (electric). The listing does not show air conditioning.
What are the property taxes for 58 Methodist Island?
Property taxes are $3,669 a year (2025), or about $306 a month.
Where is 58 Methodist Island?
58 Methodist Island is in the Port McNicoll community of Tay. The nearest main intersection is Methodist Island. The postal code is L0K 1R0.
Is 58 Methodist Island still for sale?
Yes. It is an active listing (MLS® S13588020). Listings here update from the board through the day and come down once a home sells.
What are similar cottages near 58 Methodist Island asking?
Similar cottages for sale nearby right now include 40 - 76 DOCK Lane at $800,000, 134 Forest Harbour Parkway at $799,900 (3 bed) and 210 Wycliffe Cove at $999,900 (3 bed). These are asking prices, not sold prices. The Sold history tab shows what homes at this address went for.
What have homes at 58 Methodist Island sold for?
Recent sales, leases and expired listings for this home and others at the same address are in the Sold history tab, with the price and date of each. It is free for members.
How do I book a showing at 58 Methodist Island?
Pick a day and time with Book a Tour on this page. Tours are free, with no obligation, in person or by video. You can also call or text 647-931-3923.
Have a different question? Ask about this home and get an answer, usually within the hour.
Similar cottages nearby
More cottages for sale near Port McNicoll, picked by style, size and price.
Land$800,00040 - 76 DOCK Lane, Tay0 bath · Port McNicollCourtesy of: CENTURY 21 PERCY FULTON LTD.View home →
Waterfront cottage$799,900134 Forest Harbour Parkway, Tay3 bed · 1 bath · Rural TayCourtesy of: RE/MAX Georgian Bay Realty LtdView home →
Waterfront cottage$999,900210 Wycliffe Cove, Tay3 bed · 4 bath · Victoria HarbourCourtesy of: RE/MAX Georgian Bay Realty LtdView home →Courtesy of: CENTURY 21 B.J. ROTH REALTY LTD.
PropTx MLS® assumes no responsibility for the accuracy of any information shown. The information provided herein must only be used by consumers that have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale or lease of real estate and may not be used for any commercial purpose or any other purpose.
*Estimated monthly cost assumes 20% down, a 4.5% rate and a 30-year amortization, plus property tax. For illustration only.