Fixer-Upper Cottages For Sale on Peninsula Lake
2 fixer-upper cottages for sale on Peninsula Lake right now, from $599K to $2.9M. Updated through the day from the MLS®.
46 photos$599,000Chalet3 bed · 2 bath · 1400-1599 sq ft30 Turner DriveChaffey, HuntsvilleCourtesy of: Royal LePage Lakes Of Muskoka Realty
50 photos$2,899,000Waterfront cottage5 bed · 4 bath · 3000-3500 sq ft577 Canal RoadBrunel, HuntsvilleCourtesy of: Sutton Group Muskoka Realty Inc.Listing data © PropTx MLS®. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Fixer-upper cottages on Peninsula Lake
Right now there are 2 fixer-upper cottages for sale on Peninsula Lake. Asking prices run from $599K to $2.9M, and the middle listing is $1.75M. Most are in Huntsville.
Peninsula Lake, known locally as Pen Lake, is Muskoka's resort lake. Read the full Peninsula Lake guide.
A dated cottage on a good lot can be the best value on a lake. Before you plan a rebuild, confirm what the township will let you do near the water. Many older cottages sit closer to the shore than current rules allow, and that grandfathered footprint can be worth more than the building.
Common questions
How many fixer-upper cottages are for sale on Peninsula Lake?
There are 2 listings right now, taken straight from the MLS® and updated through the day. New ones are added the day they come on the market.
How much do fixer-upper cottages on Peninsula Lake cost?
Asking prices run from $599K to $2.9M, with a median of $1.75M. Frontage, shoreline, exposure, road access and the building itself account for most of the spread.
Where on Peninsula Lake are these fixer-upper cottages?
Most of today's listings are in Huntsville. Use the map above to see exactly where each one sits on the lake.
Can I get new fixer-upper cottages on Peninsula Lake sent to me?
Yes. Save this search or ask for listing alerts and new fixer-upper cottages on Peninsula Lake are emailed to you the day they hit the MLS®, along with price drops. It is free and you can stop anytime.
More ways to shop Peninsula Lake
- Waterfront Cottages 35
- Luxury Cottages 4
- Under $500,000 18
- Under $750,000 27
- Under $1 Million 30
- Under $2 Million 31
- Cheap Cottages 14
- Four-Season Cottages 34
- Island & Water Access Cottages 2
- Cottages with a Boathouse 2
- Cottages with a Sandy Beach 34
- Cottages with a Bunkie 1
- Investor-Friendly Cottages 9
- Cabins 7
- Chalets 5
- Resort Condos 28
Fixer-Upper Cottages on other Muskoka lakes
All fixer-upper cottages in Muskoka · All fixer-upper cottages in Ontario
Peninsula Lake sold prices by year
219 cottages, homes and lots on Peninsula Lake have sold through the MLS® since 2018, 25 of them in the past 12 months. Sold prices are for members. Joining is free.
Free members see sold prices, sale-to-asking ratios and every sold listing on the lake.
| Year | Sales | Median sold | Average | Lowest | Highest | Sold vs. asking | Median days |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 to date | 22 | ||||||
| 2025 | 23 | ||||||
| 2024 | 24 | ||||||
| 2023 | 30 | ||||||
| 2022 | 34 | ||||||
| 2021 | 61 | ||||||
| 2020 | 19 | ||||||
| 2019 | 3 | ||||||
| 2018 | 3 | ||||||
Sold data from the PropTx MLS®, for sales reported on the board. Private and exclusive sales are not included. Figures are a guide, not an appraisal. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Ready to find your cottage in Peninsula Lake?
Talk to a cottage specialist today. Honest answers, no pressure.