Peninsula Lake Cottages For Sale Under $500,000
18 cottages under $500,000 for sale on Peninsula Lake right now, from $160K to $450K. Updated through the day from the MLS®.
New14 photos$412,500Resort condo1 bed · 1 bath · 600-699 sq ft301 - 34 Deerhurst Greens RoadChaffey, HuntsvilleCourtesy of: Royal LePage Meadowtowne Realty
New31 photos$239,900Resort condo1 bed · 1 bath · 600-699 sq ft202 - 54 Deerhurst Summit DriveChaffey, HuntsvilleCourtesy of: Harvey Kalles Real Estate Ltd.
New35 photos$239,900Resort condo1 bed · 1 bath · 600-699 sq ft201 - 54 Deerhurst Summit DriveChaffey, HuntsvilleCourtesy of: Harvey Kalles Real Estate Ltd.
12 photos$159,900Resort condo1 bed · 1 bath · 0-499 sq ft402 - 402 Bayshore - Deerhurst DriveChaffey, HuntsvilleCourtesy of: Sutton Group Muskoka Realty Inc.
14 photos$159,900Resort condo1 bed · 1 bath · 0-499 sq ft421 - 421 Bayshore - Deerhurst DriveChaffey, HuntsvilleCourtesy of: Sutton Group Muskoka Realty Inc.
22 photos$255,000Resort condo1 bed · 1 bath · 500-599 sq ft52-205 Deerhurst DriveChaffey, HuntsvilleCourtesy of: Sutton Group Muskoka Realty Inc.
19 photos$249,900Resort condo1 bed · 1 bath · 500-599 sq ft54-203 - 54-203 Deerhurst DriveChaffey, HuntsvilleCourtesy of: Sutton Group Muskoka Realty Inc.
20 photos$399,900Resort condo1 bed · 1 bath · 500-599 sq ft425 - 25 Pen Lake Point RoadChaffey, HuntsvilleCourtesy of: SUTTON GROUP-ADMIRAL REALTY INC.
29 photos$325,000Chalet1 bed · 1 bath · 500-599 sq ft422 - 25 PEN LAKE POINT RoadChaffey, HuntsvilleCourtesy of: Coldwell Banker Thompson Real Estate
47 photos$449,000Chalet3 bed · 2 bath · 700-1100 sq ft1616 Skyline DriveChaffey, HuntsvilleCourtesy of: Royal LePage Lakes Of Muskoka Realty
30 photos$325,000Resort condo1 bed · 1 bath · 600-699 sq ft52-105 - 1235 Deerhurst DriveHuntsvilleCourtesy of: RE/MAX TWIN CITY REALTY INC.
27 photos$449,900Chalet2 bed · 1 bath · 1500-2000 sq ft213 Woodland DriveChaffey, HuntsvilleCourtesy of: Sutton Group Muskoka Realty Inc.Listing data © PropTx MLS®. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Peninsula Lake cottage market today
Based on 18 homes for sale right now (asking prices). Updated through the day.
Homes by price
By style
| Style | For sale | Median price |
|---|---|---|
| Waterfront cottage | 18 | $330K |
| Resort condo | 16 | $325K |
| Chalet | 3 | $449K |
| Cottage | 2 | $449K |
Thinking of selling here?
See what your home could sell for against these 18 listings.
Get my instant estimateCottages under $500,000 on Peninsula Lake
Right now there are 18 cottages under $500,000 for sale on Peninsula Lake. Asking prices run from $160K to $450K, and the middle listing is $330K. Most are in Huntsville.
Peninsula Lake, known locally as Pen Lake, is Muskoka's resort lake. Read the full Peninsula Lake guide.
Common questions
How many cottages under $500,000 are for sale on Peninsula Lake?
There are 18 listings right now, taken straight from the MLS® and updated through the day. New ones are added the day they come on the market.
How much do cottages under $500,000 on Peninsula Lake cost?
Asking prices run from $160K to $450K, with a median of $330K. Frontage, shoreline, exposure, road access and the building itself account for most of the spread.
Where on Peninsula Lake are these cottages under $500,000?
Most of today's listings are in Huntsville. Use the map above to see exactly where each one sits on the lake.
Can I get new cottages under $500,000 on Peninsula Lake sent to me?
Yes. Save this search or ask for listing alerts and new cottages under $500,000 on Peninsula Lake are emailed to you the day they hit the MLS®, along with price drops. It is free and you can stop anytime.
More ways to shop Peninsula Lake
- Waterfront Cottages 35
- Luxury Cottages 4
- Under $750,000 27
- Under $1 Million 30
- Under $2 Million 31
- Cheap Cottages 14
- Four-Season Cottages 34
- Island & Water Access Cottages 2
- Cottages with a Boathouse 2
- Cottages with a Sandy Beach 34
- Cottages with a Bunkie 1
- Investor-Friendly Cottages 9
- Fixer-Upper Cottages 2
- Cabins 7
- Chalets 5
- Resort Condos 28
Under $500,000 on other Muskoka lakes
- Lake of Bays 41
- Lake Muskoka 23
- Lake Joseph 15
- Lake Rosseau 5
- Big East River 4
- Mary Lake 3
- Gloucester Pool 3
- Lake Vernon 2
- Sparrow Lake 2
- Kahshe Lake 2
- Six Mile Lake 1
- Stewart Lake 1
All cottages under $500,000 in Muskoka · All cottages under $500,000 in Ontario
Peninsula Lake sold prices by year
219 cottages, homes and lots on Peninsula Lake have sold through the MLS® since 2018, 25 of them in the past 12 months. Sold prices are for members. Joining is free.
Free members see sold prices, sale-to-asking ratios and every sold listing on the lake.
| Year | Sales | Median sold | Average | Lowest | Highest | Sold vs. asking | Median days |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 to date | 22 | ||||||
| 2025 | 23 | ||||||
| 2024 | 24 | ||||||
| 2023 | 30 | ||||||
| 2022 | 34 | ||||||
| 2021 | 61 | ||||||
| 2020 | 19 | ||||||
| 2019 | 3 | ||||||
| 2018 | 3 | ||||||
Sold data from the PropTx MLS®, for sales reported on the board. Private and exclusive sales are not included. Figures are a guide, not an appraisal. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Ready to find your cottage in Peninsula Lake?
Talk to a cottage specialist today. Honest answers, no pressure.