Skip to content
647-931-3923 info@cottageconnect.com
Cottages & waterfront for sale across Ontario cottage country
SwipeNEW

Island & Water Access Cottages For Sale on Lake Erie

18 island and water access cottages for sale on Lake Erie right now, from $360K to $4.75M. Updated through the day from the MLS®.

Lake Erie marketMedian $1.4M18 for sale~86 days on marketMarket stats
Tap a price to see the home
18 island and water access cottages for sale on Lake Erie
Lot B - 1079 Bay Street, Norfolk29 photos$599,900Waterfront cottage2 bed · 3 bath · 1100-1500 sq ftLot B - 1079 Bay StreetPort Rowan, NorfolkGarage · 3 parking · Lot 35.3 x 153.4 ftCourtesy of: COLDWELL BANKER MOMENTUM REALTY, BROKERAGELot A - 1079 Bay Street, Norfolk29 photos$599,900Waterfront cottage2 bed · 3 bath · 1100-1500 sq ftLot A - 1079 Bay StreetPort Rowan, NorfolkGarage · 3 parking · Lot 34.9 x 162.6 ftCourtesy of: COLDWELL BANKER MOMENTUM REALTY, BROKERAGE1033 FIRELANE 1 Road, Port Colborne50 photos$2,250,000Waterfront cottage7+3 bed · 4 bath · 3500-5000 sq ft1033 FIRELANE 1 Road874 - Sherkston, Port ColborneGarage · 22 parking · Lot 205.5 x 606 ftCourtesy of: Century 21 Heritage House LTD17 Black Walnut Drive, Norfolk$2,000,000Waterfront cottage2 bed · 2 bath · 2000-2500 sq ft17 Black Walnut DriveSt. Williams, NorfolkGarage · 8 parking · Lot 78.7 x 305.4 ftCourtesy of: RE/MAX ESCARPMENT REALTY INC.2391 Firelane 2 Road, Port Colborne41 photos$1,398,000Waterfront cottage5 bed · 2 bath · 1500-2000 sq ft2391 Firelane 2 Road874 - Sherkston, Port ColborneGarage · 9 parking · Pool · Lot 100 x 496.7 ftCourtesy of: RE/MAX NIAGARA REALTY LTD, BROKERAGE21 Villella Road, Haldimand19 photos$459,900Waterfront cottage1 bath · 700-1100 sq ft21 Villella RoadDunnville, HaldimandGarage · 7 parking · Lot 150 x 220 ftCourtesy of: KING REALTY INC.27 Hickory Hollow, Haldimand42 photos$359,999Waterfront cottage3 bed · 2 bath · 1100-1500 sq ft27 Hickory HollowNanticoke, HaldimandGarage · 3 parking · PoolCourtesy of: MICHAEL ST.JEAN REALTY INC.177 Lakeshore Road W, Port Colborne48 photos$999,000Waterfront cottage3 bed · 3 bath · 1100-1500 sq ft177 Lakeshore Road W878 - Sugarloaf, Port ColborneGarage · 5 parking · Lot 50 x 150 ftCourtesy of: REVEL Realty Inc., Brokerage10417 Lakeshore Road, Wainfleet37 photos$1,399,999Waterfront cottage3 bed · 2 bath · 2000-2500 sq ft10417 Lakeshore Road880 - Lakeshore, WainfleetGarage · 7 parking · Lot 50 x 325 ftCourtesy of: REVEL Realty Inc., Brokerage3067 Thunder Bay Road, Fort Erie50 photos$4,749,000Waterfront cottage5 bed · 6 bath · 5000 + sq ft3067 Thunder Bay Road335 - Ridgeway, Fort ErieGarage · 8 parking · Lot 104 x 710 ftCourtesy of: REVEL Realty Inc., Brokerage3176 Lakeshore Road, Haldimand49 photos$1,495,000Waterfront cottage3+2 bed · 4 bath · 2500-3000 sq ft3176 Lakeshore RoadDunnville, HaldimandGarage · 9 parking · Lot 46.5 x 105.7 ftCourtesy of: ROYAL LEPAGE STATE REALTY3561 Yacht Harbour Road, Fort Erie47 photos$2,490,000Waterfront cottage5 bed · 4 bath · 3500-5000 sq ft3561 Yacht Harbour Road335 - Ridgeway, Fort ErieGarage · 5 parking · Lot 72.3 x 352 ftCourtesy of: RE/MAX NIAGARA REALTY LTD, BROKERAGE

Listing data © PropTx MLS®. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Market snapshot

Lake Erie cottage market today

Based on 18 homes for sale right now (asking prices). Updated through the day.

Get recent sold prices
Median asking price$1.4MRange $360K – $4.75M
Homes for sale183 new this month
Typical days on market86Room to negotiate
Median price / sq ft$604From listed size ranges

Homes by price

Under $700K6
$700K–$1M2
$1M–$1.5M3
$1.5M–$2M0
$2M–$3M6
$3M+1

By style

StyleFor saleMedian price
Waterfront cottage18$1.4M
Cottage18$1.4M
Log home1$3M

Thinking of selling here?

See what your home could sell for against these 18 listings.

Get my instant estimate
Lake Erie

Island and water access cottages on Lake Erie

Right now there are 18 island and water access cottages for sale on Lake Erie. Asking prices run from $360K to $4.75M, and the middle listing is $1.4M. Most are in Haldimand County, Fort Erie, Port Colborne and Norfolk County.

The southernmost, shallowest and warmest of the Great Lakes, with Ontario along its whole north shore. More about Lake Erie.

Water access cottages usually cost less than road access cottages on the same lake and offer more privacy. In return you need a boat, a mainland parking spot and a place to land, and you carry in everything you use. Lenders and insurers treat them differently, so speak to both early.

Common questions

How many island and water access cottages are for sale on Lake Erie?

There are 18 listings right now, taken straight from the MLS® and updated through the day. New ones are added the day they come on the market.

How much do island and water access cottages on Lake Erie cost?

Asking prices run from $360K to $4.75M, with a median of $1.4M. Frontage, shoreline, exposure, road access and the building itself account for most of the spread.

Where on Lake Erie are these island and water access cottages?

Most of today's listings are in Haldimand County, Fort Erie, Port Colborne and Norfolk County. Use the map above to see exactly where each one sits on the lake.

Can I get new island and water access cottages on Lake Erie sent to me?

Yes. Save this search or ask for listing alerts and new island and water access cottages on Lake Erie are emailed to you the day they hit the MLS®, along with price drops. It is free and you can stop anytime.

Sold history

Lake Erie sold prices by year

723 cottages, homes and lots on Lake Erie have sold through the MLS® since 2017, 106 of them in the past 12 months. Sold prices are for members. Joining is free.

See what Lake Erie cottages actually sold for

Free members see sold prices, sale-to-asking ratios and every sold listing on the lake.

YearSalesMedian soldAverageLowestHighestSold vs. askingMedian days
2026 to date101
202587
202452
202352
202262
2021136
2020105
201956
201864
20178

Sold data from the PropTx MLS®, for sales reported on the board. Private and exclusive sales are not included. Figures are a guide, not an appraisal. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Ready to find your cottage in Lake Erie?

Talk to a cottage specialist today. Honest answers, no pressure.

© Cottage Connect · Will Balo, Sales Representative, RE/MAX Experts
Privacy Policy Terms of Use Photo Credits