Skip to content
647-619-2256 info@cottageconnect.com
Cottages & waterfront for sale across Ontario cottage country
SwipeNEW
Every cottage for sale in Ontario cottage country

Cottages for sale

Homes matching "Port McNicoll". Use the filters to narrow by style, price, bedrooms and area.

MarketMedian $500K11 for sale+1 new this week~86 days on marketMarket stats
Tap a price to see the home
13 cottages for sale
7 Dock Lane, TayNew41 photos$1,699,900Waterfront cottage3 bed · 3 bath · 2000-2500 sq ft7 Dock LanePort McNicoll, TayGarage · 6 parkingCourtesy of: FARIS TEAM REAL ESTATE BROKERAGE40 - 76 DOCK Lane, Tay6 photos$800,000Land0 bath40 - 76 DOCK LanePort McNicoll, TayPOTL fee $177/moCourtesy of: CENTURY 21 PERCY FULTON LTD.503 Margaret Street, Tay2 photos$129,900Land0 bath · < 700 sq ft503 Margaret StreetPort McNicoll, TayLot 60 x 117.4 ftCourtesy of: Team Hawke RealtyLot 86 - 548 Fifth Avenue, Tay$79,969Land0 bathLot 86 - 548 Fifth AvenuePort McNicoll, TayLot 56 x 112 ftCourtesy of: ICI SOURCE REAL ASSET SERVICES INC.15 Swan Lane, Tay8 photos$369,900Land0 bath · < 700 sq ft15 Swan LanePort McNicoll, TayLot 94.6 x 203 ftCourtesy of: HOMELIFE FRONTIER REALTY INC.10 & 11 Methodist Island, Tay49 photos$499,900Waterfront cottage4 bed · 1 bath · 700-1100 sq ft10 & 11 Methodist IslandPort McNicoll, TayLot 200.6 x 144.4 ftCourtesy of: Keller Williams Home Group Realty58 Methodist Island, Tay25 photos$899,900Waterfront cottage3 bed · 2 bath · 1100-1500 sq ft58 Methodist IslandPort McNicoll, TayLot 77.1 x 220 ftCourtesy of: CENTURY 21 B.J. ROTH REALTY LTD.440 David Avenue, Tay8 photos$119,900Land0 bath440 David AvenuePort McNicoll, TayLot 62.5 x 104.9 ftCourtesy of: RE/MAX Georgian Bay Realty Ltd27 - 53 Dock Lane E, Tay27 photos$2,099,900Waterfront cottage4 bed · 3 bath · 3000-3500 sq ft27 - 53 Dock Lane EPort McNicoll, TayPOTL fee $271/mo · Garage · 4 parkingCourtesy of: Century 21 B.J. Roth Realty Ltd.247 Dignard Avenue, Tay$54,900Land0 bath247 Dignard AvenuePort McNicoll, TayLot 58 x 131.7 ftCourtesy of: Team Hawke Realty426 Seventh Avenue, Tay5 photos$124,900Land0 bath · < 700 sq ft426 Seventh AvenuePort McNicoll, TayLot 75 x 115 ftCourtesy of: RE/MAX HALLMARK PEGGY HILL GROUP REALTY18 Swan Lane, Tay40 photos$1,749,900Resort condo4 bed · 3 bath · 2500-3000 sq ft18 Swan LanePort McNicoll, TayGarage · 7 parkingCourtesy of: ICI SOURCE REAL ASSET SERVICES INC.

Listing data © PropTx MLS®. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Market snapshot

Market snapshot

Based on 11 homes for sale right now (asking prices). Updated through the day.

Get recent sold prices
Median asking price$500KRange $120K – $2.1M
Homes for sale11+1 new this week
Typical days on market86Room to negotiate
Median price / sq ft$629From listed size ranges

Homes by price

Under $700K6
$700K–$1M2
$1M–$1.5M0
$1.5M–$2M2
$2M–$3M1
$3M+0

By style

StyleFor saleMedian price
Waterfront cottage7$900K
Land6$149K
Cottage4$1.3M
Resort condo1$1.75M

Thinking of selling here?

See what your home could sell for against these 11 listings.

Get my instant estimate

Ready to find your cottage?

Talk to a cottage specialist today. Honest answers, no pressure.

Contact a specialistCall 647-619-2256

Popular Searches

Popular Areas

Useful Links

© Cottage Connect · Will Balo, Sales Representative, RE/MAX Experts
Privacy Policy Terms of Use Photo Credits

© 2026 Cottage Connect. All rights reserved. PropTx MLS® assumes no responsibility for the accuracy of any information shown. The information provided herein must only be used by consumers that have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale or lease of real estate and may not be used for any commercial purpose or any other purpose.

Cottage Connect is not a brokerage. RE/MAX Experts | Sales Representative | 647-619-2256 | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy

The trademarks MLS®, Multiple Listing Service® and the associated logos are owned by The Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA.